Last December, 50 houses and PUDs were for sale in Montecito, and six were pending, according to the Santa Barbara Association of Realtors' December 2025 chart. The same chart put Montecito at 8.3 months of inventory. For a seller whose home has been listed since summer, that number makes pulling the listing until spring look like the obvious move.
Both numbers fell last winter, and the pending count fell much further. Between October and December 2025, Montecito's active listings dropped from 70 to 50 and pending sales dropped from 17 to 6. Thanksgiving is a week away, and a Montecito seller deciding whether to stay listed, reprice or withdraw should look at both halves of the inventory figure, along with how quickly each one recovered in January.
The Winter Inventory Figure Moves With the Pending Count
SBAOR's months-of-inventory figure for Montecito matches active listings divided by pending sales in every month below. Last winter, the active count moved within a narrow band and the pending count swung widely.
| Month | Closed | Median sale price | Pending | Active | Months of inventory |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| September 2025 | 12 | $6,515,000 | 12 | 79 | 6.6 |
| October 2025 | 17 | $7,000,000 | 17 | 70 | 4.1 |
| November 2025 | 15 | $8,300,000 | 8 | 65 | 8.1 |
| December 2025 | 5 | $5,300,000 | 6 | 50 | 8.3 |
| January 2026 | 8 | $5,525,000 | 10 | 52 | 5.2 |
| February 2026 | 8 | $4,342,500 | 13 | 57 | 4.4 |
| March 2026 | 14 | $5,650,000 | 16 | 59 | 3.7 |
| September 2026 | 15 | $5,285,000 | 23 | 66 | 2.9 |
| October 2026 | 20 | $5,025,000 | 16 | 60 | 3.8 |
Between October and November 2025, active listings went from 70 to 65 and pending sales fell from 17 to 8. Months of inventory nearly doubled because the pending count was cut in half while the active count slipped by five. Last November's median of $8.3 million on 15 closings also shows how much a single month's mix can swing a Montecito median. That number says little about what any one house is worth.
December Had the Fewest Competing Listings of the Year
Last December's 50 active listings were the lowest count on the table. That was 15 fewer than in November and 20 fewer than in October 2025. A seller who stayed listed through December 2025 was one of 50 choices in Montecito, the smallest field any buyer saw between that September and the following March.
The pending count was low too, and it recovered month by month. Montecito had 6 pending sales in December, 10 in January, 13 in February and 16 in March. A home already on the market in December was there the whole time that count rose. Mark Ashton Hunt wrote in the Montecito Journal that the weeks after Thanksgiving are "a calm before the holidays and end of year" and "always a special time in Montecito." A buyer touring in that stretch had fewer Montecito homes to choose from than at any other point last winter.
January Brings the Relisted Homes Back Together
Montecito active listings went from 50 in December to 52 in January, 57 in February and 59 by March 2026. Across SBAOR's South Coast house and PUD districts, a wider area than Montecito alone, January 2026 had 38 expired listings and 111 new listings. November 2025 had 13 expirations and 71 new listings.
Those numbers show the "pull it and relist in the new year" plan from the other side. Across the South Coast, new listings in January 2026 ran well ahead of November's. A home withdrawn in December and relisted in February enters a field that has grown back toward 60 listings. In February 2026, that meant 57 active listings sharing 13 pending sales.
This Fall Starts From a Tighter Position
On SBAOR's October 2026 chart, Montecito had 60 active listings, 16 pending sales and 3.8 months of inventory. A year earlier it had 70 active, 17 pending and 4.1 months. Montecito's 3.8 months was still the deepest supply on the South Coast that month. Carpinteria and Summerland were at 3.6, Santa Barbara at 2.7, Goleta at 2.4 and Hope Ranch at 1.6. Through October 2026, Montecito recorded 132 closings at a $5.725 million median, compared with 144 closings at $6.1675 million through October 2025.
Prices have changed more than the counts have. Montecito's October median was $5.025 million in 2026 and $7 million in 2025. A median built on 20 sales moves with the mix of homes that closed, but local reporting points the same way. In his September 1 Montecito Journal column, Hunt described price "softenings," "many homes are reducing in price," and homes that sold a year or two ago coming back "at similar or lower prices." He estimated active listings were up about 15% between early July and August 22. In the same column he counted more than 20 properties in escrow and 22 sales in 93108 over the previous six weeks, four of them above $10 million. Buyers kept buying this fall, and they were selective about price.
If this winter follows last winter, pending sales will drop in November and December, active listings will thin by the end of the year, and the months-of-inventory figure will jump. The November 2026 chart should come out in early December. A seller who expects the spike will read it calmly.
Price Decides What the Calendar Can't
The hold-or-pull decision often hides the real question of whether the asking price fits this market. Hunt's 2025 year in review said many Montecito homes "start out with astronomical asking prices, many of which reduced multiple times in 2025 before finding a buyer," while "others went over-asking." One of the over-asking sales was 155 Santa Isabel Lane. It was listed at $6.35 million and sold for $7.55 million within days. Across SBAOR's South Coast house and PUD districts in October 2026, homes sold at 92.77% of their final list price and 91.23% of their original list price. The gap between those two figures comes from price reductions made before a buyer signed.
Hunt also wrote that Montecito "can be affected each month by just a handful of sales," and that "it takes many months of down sales in a row to become a trend toward a slowing market." His point applies to a single listing too. In a market of about 15 sales a month, one well-priced home can stand out in December, and an overpriced one can sit there through March.
Each option has a different cost this winter:
- Stay listed at the current price. You face the fewest competing listings of the year and few buyers, and your days on market keep adding up. This makes sense when recent comparable sales already support the price.
- Reduce the price before Thanksgiving. You face the same small field of rival listings, and the reduction reaches the buyers still touring in December before the January wave of new listings arrives. Last winter, the pending count started climbing in January.
- Withdraw and relist after New Year's. Last year, a home relisted in the new year re-entered a field that had grown from 50 homes in December to 57 by February and 59 by March.
- Sell privately through the winter. Some Montecito sales happen outside the open market. For an owner who wants a quiet test of the price over the holidays, a private sale is an option. Our notes on how off-market sales work in Montecito and on pricing a luxury home in Montecito go further on both.
Common Questions
Will the months-of-inventory figure jump again this December? Last year it went from 4.1 months in October to 8.3 in December. Most of that rise came from pending sales falling from 17 to 6 while active listings fell from 70 to 50. A similar seasonal pattern would push the figure up again even if the number of homes for sale shrinks.
Is a lower Montecito median a sign that my home lost value? A monthly median built on 15 or 20 closings moves with the mix of homes that sold. Recent comparable sales near your home and on your street, together with the current competing listings, show more about your home's value than any one month's median.
How quickly did the Montecito pending count recover after the holidays? Last winter, pending sales went from 6 in December to 10 in January, 13 in February and 16 in March 2026, and active listings grew from 50 to 59 over the same months.
If your Montecito home is on the market now, or you're deciding whether to list it before the holidays, Nico Pollero can review your price against current competing listings and recent comparable sales. Request a private consultation to plan your listing for December and January, and to receive our pocket listings. You can also start with a home valuation or read more on selling with our team.